民机重着陆典型案例分析研究

Analysis of typical cases of heavy landing in civil aircraft

摘要

近十年来，民航飞机的重着陆事故引起了广泛关注，约1/3的民航飞机安全事故与着陆相关，其中重着陆事故几乎占着陆事故的1/5。重着陆不仅对飞机结构造成损害，严重时甚至会导致飞机毁坏或人员伤亡。然而，关于重着陆的统计数据仍不足。本研究通过定量标准、仿真分析和机器学习方法，系统研究了重着陆的判定标准及其对飞机结构的损伤模式，并通过对波音737、空客A320等主流机型过去十年内53起典型重着陆事故进行了详细统计与分析。研究结果表明，重着陆事故通常会对飞机的起落架、机身、机翼等关键部件造成不同程度的损伤；不同类型的重着陆事故对飞机结构的破坏程度差异显著。

Abstract

In the past decade, approximately one-third of civil aviation safety incidents have been related to landing, with hard landings comprising one-fifth of these landing-related incidents. Hard landings not only damage aircraft structures but also can lead to aircraft destruction or loss of life in severe cases. However, statistical data on hard landings remain limited. This paper systematically analyzes hard landing criteria through a review of quantitative standards, simulation analysis, and machine learning techniques. It also conducts a statistical examination of 53 typical hard landing incidents of mainstream aircraft such as Boeing-737 and Airbus-A320 over the past decade, offering a detailed exploration of common structural damage patterns associated with hard landings. Results show that heavy landing incidents often cause damage of different degrees to the aircraft's landing gear, fuselage, wings, and other key components. Moreover, the extent of damage differs significantly among various types of heavy landing incidents.

关键词

民航飞机安全事故 / 重着陆 / 仿真建模 / 机器学习 / 案例分析

Key words

civil aviation safety incident / heavy landing / simulation modeling / machine learning / case analysis

参考文献

[1] Boeing. Aircraft maintenance manual Boeing 737 documentation [EB/OL]. (2016-11-02)[2024-12-01]. https://wtruib.ru/boeing_737/amm/.

[2] Boeing. 737 Flight crew operations manual [EB/OL]. (2021-06-15)[2024-12-01]. https://boredaviator.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/B737-300-FCOM-.pdf.

[3] Airbus. Airbus A320 A319/A320/A321 aircraft maintenance manual [EB/OL]. [2024-11-12]. https://manualzz.com/doc/32187428/airbus-a320-a319-a320-a321-aircraft-maintenance-manual#google_vignette.

[4] Wikipedia. Hard landing [EB/OL]. [2024-11-15]. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hard_landing.

[5] International Civil Aviation Organization. Homepage [EB/OL]. [2024-10-11]. https://www.icao.int/.

[6] National Transportation Safety Board. Homepage [EB/OL]. [2024-10-20]. https://www.ntsb.gov/Pages/home.aspx.

[7] Aviation Safety Network. Homepage [EB/OL]. [2024-11-21]. https://asn.flightsafety.org/.

[8] 王帅, 马昊, 陈吉明. 多型重着陆的分析及建议[J]. 综合运输, 2024, 46(1): 125-133.

[9] WANG Shuai, MA Hao, CHEN Jiming. Analysis on multi type heavy landing[J]. China transportation review, 2024, 46(1): 125-133(in Chinese).

[10] 蔡景, 蔡坤烨, 黄世杰. 基于实时监测参数的民用飞机重着陆预警方法[J]. 交通运输工程学报, 2022, 22(2): 298-309.

[11] CAI Jing, CAI Kunye, HUANG Shijie. Early warning method for heavy landing of civil aircraft based on real-time monitoring parameters[J]. Journal of traffic and transportation engineering, 2022, 22(2): 298-309(in Chinese).

[12] 郑磊, 池宏, 许保光, 等. 飞机重着陆预警分析方法[J]. 数学的实践与认识, 2019, 49(3): 56-72.

[13] ZHENG Lei, CHI Hong, XU Baoguang, et al. Method of early warning analysis for aircraft hard landing[J]. Mathematics in practice and theory, 2019, 49(3): 56-72(in Chinese).

[14] 孙瑞山, 张思远, 汪磊. 基于统计过程控制的QAR数据风险预测方法[J]. 统计与决策, 2015(21): 33-36.

[15] SUN Ruishan, ZHANG Siyuan, WANG Le i. Risk prediction method of QAR data based on statistical process control[J]. Statistics & decision, 2015(21): 33-36(in Chinese).

[16] 汪磊, 孙瑞山, 吴昌旭, 等. 基于飞行QAR数据的重着陆风险定量评价模型[J]. 中国安全科学学报, 2014, 24(2): 88-92.

[17] WANG Lei, SUN Ruishan, WU Changxu, et al. A flight QAR data based model for hard landing risk quantitative evaluation[J]. China safety science journal, 2014, 24(2): 88-92(in Chinese).

[18] WANG X Z, WANG H, XU B H. Risk assessment and prediction of aircraft fleet hard landing based on QAR exceedance events[C]// 2022 IEEE 4th International Conference on Civil Aviation Safety and Information Technology (ICCASIT). Piscataway, NJ, USA: IEEE, 2022: 352-357.

[19] KONG Y X, ZHANG X G, MAHADEVAN S. Bayesian deep learning for aircraft hard landing safety assessment[J]. IEEE transactions on intelligent transportation systems, 2022, 23(10): 17062-17076.

[20] LI X, SHANG J X, ZHENG L J, et al. CurveCluster+: curve clustering for hard landing pattern recognition and risk evaluation based on flight data[J]. IEEE transactions on intelligent transportation systems, 2022, 23(8): 12811-12821.

[21] ZHENG L, XIE J, QIAN S. Risk prediction method of aircraft hard landing based on flight data[M]// Safety and Reliability-Safe Societies in a Changing World. [S.l.]: CRC Press, 2018: 1827-1832.

[22] SUN R S, LI C F. A risk prediction model of hard landing based on random forest algorithm[C]// 5th International Workshop on Advances in Energy Science and Environment Engineering (AESEE 2021). Les Ulis, France: EDP Sciences, 2021: 02080.

[23] 许桂梅, 黄圣国. 基于优化支持向量机的飞机重着陆智能诊断[J]. 计算机测量与控制, 2011, 19(2): 256-259.

[24] XU Guimei, HUANG Shengguo. Airplane's hard landing diagnosis based on optimized support vector machine[J]. Computer measurement & control, 2011, 19(2): 256-259(in Chinese).

[25] 聂磊, 黄圣国, 舒平, 等. 基于支持向量机(SVM)的民用飞机重着陆智能诊断研究[J]. 中国安全科学学报, 2009, 19(7): 149-153.

[26] NIE Lei, HUANG Shengguo, SHU Ping, et al. Intelligent diagnosis for hard landing of aircraft based on SVM[J]. China safety science journal, 2009, 19(7): 149-153(in Chinese).

[27] 曹海鹏, 舒平, 黄圣国. 基于神经网络的民用飞机重着陆诊断技术研究[J]. 计算机测量与控制, 2008, 16(7): 906-908.

[28] CAO Haipeng, SHU Ping, HUANG Shengguo. Study of aircraft hard landing diagnosis based on nerual network[J]. Computer measurement & control, 2008, 16(7): 906-908(in Chinese).

[29] 曹海鹏. B737重着陆诊断技术研究[D]. 南京: 南京航空航天大学, 2008.

[30] 李波, 沈航. 飞机着陆下沉速度最大值的确定方法[J]. 应用力学学报, 2008, 25(1): 168-171.

[31] LI Bo, SHEN Hang. Determineation to maximum aircraft sinking speed[J]. Chinese journal of applied mechanics, 2008, 25(1): 168-171(in Chinese).

[32] 中国民用航空局. 运输类飞机适航标准: CAR-25-R4[S]. 北京: 中国民用航空局, 2016.

[33] Boeing. Boeing 747-400 aircraft maintenance manual[M]. Washington D.C., USA: Boeing Company, 2006.

[34] Airbus. Aircraft maintenance manual temporary revision[M]. Toulouse: Airbus, 2006.

[35] 钱宇, 叶亮. 民航运输飞机重着陆研究综述[J]. 科学技术与工程, 2021, 21(31): 13211-13220.

[36] QIAN Yu, YE Liang. Summary of research on civil commercial transport aircraft hard landing[J]. Science technology and engineering, 2021, 21(31): 13211-13220(in Chinese).

[37] OH Y K, SIMS K, SHIN K S. A study of the effects of hard landing on aircraft structure[J]. Journal of the Korea Institute of Military Science and Technology, 2011, 14(5): 805-811.

[38] CRISTIANI D, COLOMBO L, ZIELINSKI W, et al. On the evaluation of a coupled sequential approach for rotorcraft landing simulation[J]. Sensors, 2020, 20(9): 2540.

[39] ESSIENUBONG I A, IKECHUKWU O, PAUL S. Finite element analysis of aircraft tire behaviour under overloaded aircraft landing phase[J]. Aeronautics and aerospace open access journal, 2018, 2(1): 32-37.

[40] LEE K B, JEONG S H, CHO J Y, et al. Hard-landing simulation by a hierarchical aircraft landing model and an extended inertia relief technique[J]. International journal of aeronautical and space sciences, 2015, 16(3): 394-406.

[41] 陈思, 孙有朝, 郑敏. 基于支持向量机的飞机重着陆风险预警模型[J]. 兵器装备工程学报, 2019, 40(9): 154-158.

[42] CHEN Si, SUN Youzhao, ZHENG Min. Heavy landing risk prewarning model based on support vector machine[J]. Journal of ordnance equipment engineering, 2019, 40(9): 154-158(in Chinese).

[43] 常文兵, 张佳宁, 周晟瀚. 基于支持向量机的飞机重着陆预测模型[J]. 飞机设计, 2017, 37(2): 19-22.

[44] CHANG Wenbing, ZHANG Jianing, ZHOU Shenghan. A prediction model of airplane hard landing based on support vector machine[J]. Aircraft design, 2017, 37(2): 19-22(in Chinese).

[45] 许桂梅, 黄圣国. 基于多核支持向量机的飞机重着陆诊断[J]. 计算机工程, 2011, 37(10): 157-159.

[46] XU Guimei, HUANG Shengguo. Airplane hard landing diagnosis based on multi-kernel support vector machine[J]. Computer engineering, 2011, 37(10): 157-159(in Chinese).

[47] HU C, ZHOU S H, XIE Y, et al. The study on hard landing prediction model with optimized parameter SVM method[C]// 2016 35th Chinese Control Conference (CCC). Piscataway, NJ, USA: IEEE, 2016: 4283-4287.

[48] WANG X H, SHU P, RONG X, et al. A decision support system based on support vector machine for hard landing of civil aircraft[C]// 2009 International Forum on Computer Science-Technology and Applications. Piscataway, NJ, USA: IEEE, 2009: 66-70.

[49] SILAGYI D V II, LIU D H. Prediction of severity of aviation landing accidents using support vector machine models[J]. Accident analysis & prevention, 2023, 187: 107043.

[50] 卢飞, 宋佳佳. 随机森林算法在擦机尾事件预测中的应用研究[J]. 安全与环境学报, 2024, 24(8): 3028-3035.

[51] LU Fei, SONG Jiajia. Research on the application of random forest algorithm in predicting tail strike events[J]. Journal of safety and environment, 2024, 24(8): 3028-3035(in Chinese).

[52] 于健, 董健康, 李佳. 基于神经网络的飞机着陆垂直载荷大诊断技术研究[J]. 中国民航飞行学院学报, 2010, 21(4): 16-18.

[53] YU Jian, DONG Jiankang, LI Jia. Research on diagnosis technology of large vertical load during aircraft landing based on neural network[J]. Journal of Civil Aviation Flight University of China, 2010, 21(4): 16-18(in Chinese).

[54] 初雪菲. 基于机器学习的民航重着陆诊断[D]. 上海: 华东师范大学, 2022.

[55] 韩韶华. 基于机器学习的飞机重着陆预测研究[D]. 天津: 中国民航大学, 2021.

[56] The Aviation Safety Network. Accident Boeing 757-251 (WL) N543US, Sunday 18 August 2019 [EB/OL]. (2019-08-18)[2024-12-01]. https://asn.flightsafety.org/wikibase/319358.

[57] The Aviation Safety Network. Accident Airbus A330-343 9M-MTA, Saturday 14 March 2015 [EB/OL]. (2015-03-14)[2024-12-09]. https://asn.flightsafety.org/wikibase/320336.

[58] The Aviation Safety Network. Accident Boeing 737-86N (WL) OK-TVT, Saturday 22 February 2014 [EB/OL]. (2014-02-22)[2024-12-10]. https://asn.flightsafety.org/wikibase/320565.

[59] SKYbrary Aviation Safety. A332, Caracas Venezuela, 2013 [EB/OL]. [2024-12-11]. https://skybrary.aero/accidents-and-incidents/a332-caracas-venezuela-2013.

[60] ATSB Transport Safety Report. Hard landing involving Boeing 737, VH-YQR [EB/OL]. (2023-12-08)[2024-12-11]. https://www.atsb.gov.au/sites/default/files/2023-12/AO-2023-010%20Final.

[61] The Aviation Safety Network. Hard landing serious incident Boeing 737-3U3 PK-GGO, Friday 22 July 2011 [EB/OL]. (2011-07-22)[2024-12-08]. https://asn.flightsafety.org/wikibase/140472.

[62] Transportation Safety Board of Canada. Aviation investigation report A12Q0161 [EB/OL]. [2024-12-08]. https://www.bst.gc.ca/eng/rapports-reports/aviation/2012/a12q0161/a12q0161.html.

[63] The Aviation Safety Network. Accident Dornier 328-110 D-CPWF, Monday 20 October 2014 [EB/OL]. (2014-10-20)[2024-12-10]. https://asn.flightsafety.org/wikibase/320423.

[64] SKYbrary Aviation Safety. AT75, Rome Fiumicino Italy, 2013 [EB/OL]. [2024-12-20]. https://skybrary.aero/accidents-and-incidents/at75-rome-fiumicino-italy-2013.

[65] The Aviation Safety Network. ASN aviation safety database results [EB/OL]. [2024-12-20]. https://asn.flightsafety.org/asndb/cat/LTLH/1/B-M.

[66] The Aviation Safety Network. Serious incident Boeing 737-82R (WL) TC-CCK, Tuesday 7 January 2020 [EB/OL]. (2020-01-07)[2024-12-22]. https://asn.flightsafety.org/wikibase/231989.

[67] The Australian Transport Safety Bureau. Hard landing involving Boeing 737-8FE, VH-YQR, Sydney Airport, New South Wales, on 10 March 2023 [EB/OL]. (2023-03-10)[2024-12-22]. https://www.atsb.gov.au/publications/investigation_reports/2024/report/ao-2023-010.

[68] Japan Transport Safety Board. Aircraft accident investigation report [EB/OL]. (2013-06-28)[2024-12-19]. https://jtsb.mlit.go.jp/eng-air_report/JA6817.pdf.

[69] The Aviation Safety Network. Accident McDonnell Douglas MD-11F N526FE, Monday 23 March 2009 [EB/OL]. (2009-03-23)[2024-12-19]. https://asn.flightsafety.org/wikibase/321535.

[70] Japan Transport Safety Board. Aircraft accident investigation report [EB/OL]. (2013-06-26)[2024-12-19]. https://jtsb.mlit.go.jp/eng-air_report/N526FE.pdf.

[71] The Aviation Safety Network. Accident Airbus A330-343 9M-MTA, Saturday 14 March 2015 [EB/OL]. (2015-03-14)[2024-12-10]. https://asn.flightsafety.org/wikibase/320336.

[72] SKYbrary Aviation Safety. SU95, Moscow Sheremetyevo Russia, 2019 [EB/OL]. [2024-12-19]. https://skybrary.aero/accidents-and-incidents/su95-moscow-sheremetyevo-russia-2019.

[73] 陈爽, 赵铭. 重着陆导致飞机机身前部结构损伤的力学分析[J]. 科技视界, 2014(23): 85- 85.

[74] CHEN Shuang, ZHAO Ming. Mechanical analysis of aircraft nose structure damage caused by hard landing[J]. Science & technology vision, 2014(23): 85- 85(in Chinese).

[75] The Aviation Safety Network. Accident Boeing 757-251 (WL) N543US, Sunday 18 August 2019 [EB/OL]. (2019-08-18)[2024-12-12]. https://asn.flightsafety.org/wikibase/319358.

[76] The Aviation Safety Network. Accident Boeing 737-230 Advanced PK-RIL, Thursday 1 November 2007 [EB/OL]. (2007-11-01)[2024-12-12]. https://asn.flightsafety.org/asndb/321841.

[77] Japan Transport Safety Board. Aircraft accident investigation report [EB/OL]. (2016-07-28)[2024-12-13]. https://jtsb.mlit.go.jp/eng-air_report/JA610A.pdf.

[78] The Aviation Safety Network. Accident Airbus A321-231 (WL) VQ-BRS, Friday 10 January 2020 [EB/OL]. (2020-01-10)[2024-12-13]. https://asn.flightsafety.org/wikibase/319257.