中美AI医学教育政策与融合机制比较
A comparative study of AI medical education policies and integration mechanisms between China and the United States
目的 从政策演进与驱动模式的内在逻辑出发,系统对比人工智能(artificial intelligence,AI)在中美医学人才培养中的融合机制差异,为中国医学教育范式智能化转型提供科学的战略路径与实践方案。 方法 采用政策文本分析法和多案例比较法开展研究。政策文本层面:系统检索中美两国政府、行业协会官网及学术数据库,依据预设的纳入排除标准,筛选2010 — 2025年AI医学教育领域国家级、行业级核心政策文件共86 份,基于政策发布主体、政策目标、实施举措建立分析框架。案例选取层面:遵循“代表性、典型性、可比性”原则,选取美国斯坦福大学医学院、梅奥诊所医学教育中心及中国北京协和医学院、复旦大学上海医学院等12 所顶尖医学院校/医学教育机构为研究案例,通过院校官网、课程大纲、已发表文献等公开资料收集案例数据,采用主题分析法纵向梳理两国政策演进阶段,横向解构案例主体在课程融合、临床实训、师资发展等方面的实施机制,结合案例分析结果提炼两国融合机制的核心特征与差异。 结果 美国形成“市场-创新”双轮驱动的“技术引领-临床深融”发展模式,政策体系以创新生态构建与伦理框架完善为核心导向;中国呈现“战略-规划”阶梯推进的“规划引领-试点探索”发展模式,政策体系具备鲜明的顶层设计优势,但在AI与医学教育的体系化融合推进方面仍有待完善。两国在知识转化效率、课程一体化程度、临床实践融合深度及师资结构优化等方面存在显著差异。 结论 我国应立足本土医疗教育国情,借鉴国际先进经验,构建“战略规划-生态构建-能力重塑”三位一体的协同发展路径,具体包括制定以能力产出为导向的医学AI素养框架、推动课程体系从“模块嵌入”向“系统重构”转型、建立“政产学研医”协同的创新共同体、完善医学AI教育评价体系并积极参与全球医学AI教育治理,以此培育适配未来智慧医疗发展需求的复合型医学人才。
Objective Starting from the internal logic of policy evolution and driving modes, this study systematically compares the differences in the integration mechanisms of artificial intelligence (AI) in medical talent training between China and the United States, so as to provide scientific strategic paths and practical plans for the intelligent transformation of China’s medical education paradigm. Methods Policy text analysis method and multiple case comparison method were adopted in the research. At the policy text level, a total of 86 national and industrial core policy documents in the field of AI medical education in China and the United States from 2010 to 2025 were systematically retrieved from government and industry association official websites and academic databases based on pre-established inclusion and exclusion criteria, and an analysis framework was established based on the policy issuing subject, policy objectives and implementation measures. At the case selection level, following the principles of “representativeness, typicality and comparability”, 12 top medical colleges/medical education institutions including Stanford University School of Medicine, Mayo Clinic Medical Education Center in the United States, Peking Union Medical College and Shanghai Medical College of Fudan University in China were selected as research cases. Case data were collected through public sources such as institutional official websites, course syllabi, and published literature. Thematic analysis was employed to trace the evolutionary stages of policies vertically and to deconstruct the implementation mechanisms of the case subjects in curriculum integration, clinical training, faculty development and other aspects horizontally. The core characteristics and differences of the integration mechanisms of the two countries were extracted combined with the case analysis results. Results The United States has formed a “technology-led and clinical deeply integrated” development mode driven by “market and innovation”, with the policy system focusing on the construction of innovation ecosystem and the improvement of ethical framework. China has presented a “planning-led and pilot exploration” development mode with the step-by-step promotion of “strategy and planning”. The policy system has distinct advantages in top-level design, but it still needs to be improved in the systematic integration and promotion of AI and medical education. There are significant differences between the two countries in the efficiency of knowledge translation, the degree of curriculum integration, the depth of clinical practice integration and the optimization of faculty structure. Conclusion Based on the national conditions of local medical education, China should learn from international advanced experience and build a tripartite synergistic development path of “strategic planning, ecosystem construction, and capability remodeling”. The specific measures include formulating an output-oriented medical AI literacy framework, promoting the transformation of curriculum system from “module embedding” to “systematic restructuring”, establishing a collaborative innovation community of “government-industry-university-research-hospital”, improving the medical AI education evaluation system and actively participating in the global governance of medical AI education, so as to cultivate interdisciplinary medical talents adapted to the development needs of future smart healthcare.
| [1] |
|
| [2] |
Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC). The role of data science in health care: A curriculum for medical students[R]. Washington DC: AAMC, 2021. |
| [3] |
The White House. Executive order on maintaining American leadership in artificial intelligence[R]. Washington DC: The White House, 2019. |
| [4] |
卫荣, 马锋, 侯梦薇, |
| [5] |
教育部, 国家卫生健康委,国家中医药管理局. 关于深化医教协同进一步推动中医药教育改革与高质量发展的实施意见[EB/OL]. (2020-11-26)[2026-01-15]. |
| [6] |
国家卫生健康委办公厅, 国家中医药局综合司, 国家疾控局综合司. 国家卫生健康委员会办公厅关于印发卫生健康行业人工智能应用场景参考指引的通知[EB/OL]. (2024-11-06)[2026-01-14]. |
| [7] |
教育部, 中央网信办, 国家发展改革委, |
| [8] |
|
| [9] |
宋雨欣, 李子怡, 丁宁. 生成式人工智能对医学教育的影响探析[J]. 中国医学教育技术, 2024, 38(3): 281-286. |
| [10] |
|
| [11] |
袁欢欢, 全祉悦, 林祎, |
| [12] |
|
| [13] |
李梦瑶, 武丽涛, 蓝茜, |
| [14] |
|
| [15] |
贾萌, 张瑛琪, 李云峰, |
| [16] |
|
| [17] |
谭祖印, 何蕾, 陈梅兰. 人工智能赋能高校文科实验室建设的发展逻辑、 挑战与实践路径[J]. 实验室研究与探索, 2024, 43(8): 225-230. |
| [18] |
弓孟春, 潘慧, 刘辉, |
国家卫生健康委医院管理研究所医疗人工智能临床应用研究(YLXX24AIB004)
湖南省高等学校教学改革研究项目(HNJG-20230102)
中南大学教育教学改革研究项目(2023jy069)
中南大学教育教学改革研究项目(2024jy178)
/
| 〈 |
|
〉 |