The author developed an evaluation index system and model to assess the security of China’s rare earth resource industrial and supply chains from three perspectives: resource-acquisition security, resource-conversion security, and resource-circulation security. This study evaluates the security of these chains from 2000 to 2023. The primary factors affecting security were identified using the obstacle degree model. Subsequently, the coupling and coordination among the three primary indicators were assessed using a modified coupling coordination model. The findings are as follows: (1) The security of China's rare earth industrial and supply chains remained stable from 2000 to 2011 but experienced irregular declines from 2012 to 2023, with the order of security being resource-circulation security>resource-acquisition security>resource-conversion security. (2) Resource-acquisition and resource-conversion security are identified as the principal impediments. The challenges are rooted in import concentration, recycling rates, product value-added rates, application-technology competitiveness, energy consumption per unit, and resource consumption coefficients. From 2000 to 2023, there has been a decline in the coupling and coordination of the rare earth industry and supply chain security. Enhancing and refining the security-improvement strategies can enhance coordination.
其中,贸易中心度和贸易自由度作为评价贸易网络的指标,不能从单个指标的角度对复杂的贸易网络进行节点安全分析,结合贸易网络中的“二八法则”进行等级划分(Cingolani et al,2018;何则等,2019; Chen et al,2020),贸易中心度和贸易自由度越接近0,则排名越靠前,安全等级越高。贸易中心度和贸易自由度安全等级划分具体如图1所示。对各指标分别赋值,结果如表5所示。
① 提升技术创新能力:稀土在新能源、新材料等战略性新兴产业中的应用价值不断提升。应鼓励企业加大研发投入,设立专项资金,支持企业在如稀土永磁材料、催化剂和储氢合金等高端应用领域持续投入研发。②培育产业集群与龙头企业:我国稀土产业集中度低,市场竞争无序。政府应引导稀土企业向产业园区集聚,形成产业集群。同时,培育具有国际竞争力的龙头企业,通过全产业链整合,提升稀土企业成本控制能力和利润空间。③推动产品高附加值化:我国稀土产业仍处于附加值较低的产品初级加工阶段。企业应加强与科研单位合作,开发如钕铁硼永磁材料等高性能稀土产品。政府可出台政策支持企业向高附加值领域发展,推动产业升级。④加强环保治理:稀土开采和分离过程中产生的环境污染问题亟待解决。政府应当激励企业增加对环境保护的资金投入,开发创新的低碳生产工艺,以达成长期可持续发展目标。
(4)提升产业链供应链系统内部协调性方面
① 资源获取与流通安全的协同:当前我国稀土进口高度集中于缅甸、马来西亚和老挝3个国家,地缘政治风险与进口集中度形成“双重锁定”。在巩固东南亚传统来源的同时,应进行区域布局优化,系统性拓展非洲、中亚和南美洲等新兴供应地,降低进口集中度的同时,分散地缘政治风险。②资源获取与转化安全的协同:资源转化安全长期低迷的关键瓶颈在于,高端应用技术竞争力不足与产品附加值率低。建议将稀土回收利用纳入战略性新兴产业支持目录,设立专项基金支持城市矿山开发。重点突破废旧永磁材料、镍氢电池和催化剂中的稀土高效回收技术,建立“回收—分离—再利用”的全链条标准体系。③资源流通与转化安全的协同:我国稀土贸易中心度和贸易自由度长期维持满分,但这种网络地位主要建立在初级产品出口规模之上,技术含量低、附加值流失严重。建议将稀土贸易网络的建设重心从“扩大出口量”转向“嵌入技术链”。具体而言,在稀土永磁材料和催化材料等我国具备比较优势的领域,推动“产品+技术+标准”的打包输出;在稀土冶炼分离等我国占据绝对优势的环节,建立国际认证体系和质量标准的制定权。
ChenZhanheng.Brief analysis of the current situation,problems and countermeasures of rare earth industry and market[C]//The 11th China Baotou Rare Earth industry Forum Expert Report collection.Baotou:People’s Government of Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region.
CuiLiang, LiXiaomei, YaoRuoxi,2023. Analysis of the coupling and coordination degree among digital logistics, ecological environment management, and regional economic growth [J].Statistics and Decision,39(1):29-33.
GaoLi, WangYi, ShenLei,et al,2014.Security evaluation of rare earth resource with PSR conceptual model[J].Journal of Wuhan University of Technology (Social Sciences Edition),27(6):990-994.
GaoSiyu, YuJing, MaLinmao,2017.Evaluation of rare earth security:improved integration algorithm and empirical application[J].Mathematics in Practice and Theory,47(3):90-101.
GuoChaoxian, XuTingting,2023.Research on the resilience and safety of China’s pharmaceutical industrial chain and supply chain[J].Economy and Management,37(3):82-93.
HeHuanlang,2014.Rare earth reserves of downstream importing countries and rare earth export policy in China[J].Journal of Finance and Economics,40(4):56-65.
HeZe, YangYu, LiuYi,et al,2019.Characteristics of evolution of global energy trading network and relationships between major countries[J].Progress in Geography,38(10):1621-1632.
HuangXiaowei, ZhangYongqi, LiHongwei,2011.Development trend and research progress of rare earth extraction in China[J].Bulletin of National Natural Science Foundation of China,25(3):134-137.
KangHongpu, XieHeping, RenShihua,et al,2022.Development strategy of China’s coal industry under the reconstruction of global industrial chain and energy supply chain[J].Strategic Study of CAE,24(6):26-37.
LiXianhai, WangDan, WuShangkun,2014.The domestic strategic mineral resources evaluation index selection:thinking based on list of key-minerals such as the United States,the European Union[J].China Mining Magazine,23(4):30-33.
LuoTing, ZhangYongqing, ZhengMinggui,et al,2022.Security assessment and early warning of potash resources in China[J].Advances in Earth Science,37(6):575-587.
JunLü, WangDeyun, WeiShuai,2017. China’s oil security evaluation and scenario prediction based on EM-PSO-SVM model[J]. Journal of China University of Geosciences(Social Sciences Edition), 17(2): 86-96.
YueLü, DengLijing,2023.Striving to improve the resilience and security of the industrial chains and supply chains:measurement and analysis on China’s automobile industrial chain[J].Journal of International Trade,(2):1-19.
[36]
钱九红,李国平,2003.中国稀土产业的发展现状[J].稀有金属,27(6):813-818.
[37]
QianJiuhong, LiGuoping,2003.Status of development of rare earth industry in China[J].Chinese Journal of Rare Metals,27(6):813-818.
WangJunchao,2015.Discussion of management policy for China’s rare-earth industry development under the new normal of mining situation[J].China Mining Magazine,24(5):6-9.
WangKewei, ZhangYin, LiuYongtuan,2025.The realistic dilemma,internal mechanism,and practical path of empowering high-quality development of rare earth industry with new quality productive forces[J].China Mining Magazine,34(2):149-157.
WangShujia, KongWei, RenLiang,et al,2021.Research on misuses and modification of coupling coordination degree model in China[J].Journal of Natural Resources,36(3):793-810.
WeiXiang, XiaAnquan, ZhaoDi,et al,2024.Exploring strategies for the sustainable development of China’s rare earth industry[J].China Mining Magazine,33():5-9.
WuYiding, WangYuting, LuoXiang,2021.The influence of supply chain stability on the upgrading of rare earth industry in China[J].Industrial Technology & Economy,40(1):42-47.
XuDeyi, WangDi, LiJunhui,et al,2023.The security connotation and index system of industry chain and supply chain of strategic mineral resources under the new development pattern[J].Journal of Huazhong Normal University (Natural Sciences),57(1):1-12.
YanXiao, ChenLianfang, YanLiang,et al,2016.Evaluation of major mineral resources’ security in China based on PSR model[J].China Mining Magazine,25(1):43-49.
ZhangAiqin, XueBiwei, ZhangHaichao,2021.Analysis on coupling coordination and spatial distribution of China’s provincial innovation ecosystem[J].On Economic Problems,(6):98-105.
ZhangSui, ZhangMei, ChiGuotai,2010.The science and technology evaluation model based on entropy weight and empirical research during the 10th five-year of China[J].Chinese Journal of Management,7(1):34-42.
ZhaoGuimei, GengYong, WeiWendong,2024.Evaluating the trade security of rare earth resources in China from a sustainable development perspective[J].Journal of China University of Geosciences (Social Sciences Edition),24(2):93-105.
ZhengGuodong, WangKun, ChenQishen,et al,2021.The change of world rare earth industrial structure and the problems faced by China’s rare earth industry[J].Acta Geoscientica Sinica,42(2):265-272.
ZhengMinggui, WenDonghong, DongJuan, et al,2026. Safety evaluation of the industrial chain and supply chain of fluorite resources in China[J]. Geological Bulletin of China, 45(2/3):221-235.
ZhengMinggui, NiJingsheng, LuoLaiwen,et al,2025.Security evaluation of industry and supply chains of petroleum resources in China[J].China Mining Magazine,34(2):99-110.
ZhengMinggui, WangPing, ZengJianlin,et al,2022.Early warning analysis on China’s natural gas national security during the 14th Five-Year Plan[J].Natural Gas Industry,42(3):129-137.
ZhouNa, WuQiaosheng, XueShuangjiao,2020.A new security evaluation framework of strategical minerals in the new era[J].China Population,Resources and Environment,30(12):55-65.
ZhouZhiyi, FanJinqi, ChengJinhua, et al,2024. Research on comprehensive evaluation and prediction of lithium resource security in China[J]. Journal of Central China Normal University (Natural Sciences), 58(5): 571-588.
ZhuXuehong, ZhangHongwei, LiXinyuan,2018.Measurement of the international market power of China’s rare earth and the effectiveness of policy[J].Journal of International Trade,(1):32-44.