1.School of Earth and Planetary Sciences, East China University of Technology, Nanchang 330013, Jiangxi, China
2.State Key Laboratory of Critical Mineral Research and Exploration, Institute of Geochemistry, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Guiyang 550081, Guizhou, China
3.Guizhou Central Laboratory of Geology and Mineral Resources, Guiyang 550018, Guizhou, China
The Western Kunlun Orogenic Belt, situated along the northern margin of the Tibetan Plateau, represents one of China’s significant polymetallic metallogenic belts. The Kukaazi deposit, located in Yecheng County, Xinjiang, is a newly identified Pb-Zn-(Cu-W) polymetallic deposit within this belt, exhibiting considerable mineralization potential. However, due to its remote location and the paucity of fundamental geological research, the sources of ore-forming materials and the genetic classification of this deposit remain ambiguous, thereby limiting the comprehension of regional metallogenic patterns and hindering further exploration efforts. The deposit comprises three ore blocks: KⅠ, KⅡ, and KⅢ, with ore bodies manifesting as lenticular and stratoid forms within the marble, metasiliciclastic rocks, and contact zones of the Mesoproterozoic Changcheng System. Based on mineral paragenetic associations and cross-cutting relationships, the mineralization process is delineated into the dry skarn stage, the copper-iron sulfide stage, and the lead-zinc sulfide stage. This study undertook a comprehensive sulfur isotope analysis of metal sulfides from the KⅠ and KⅡ ore blocks, alongside a lead isotope analysis of metal sulfides, host rocks, and intrusive rocks, based on an in-depth characterization of the deposit’s geological features and mineralization stages. The objective was to trace the sources of ore-forming materials and elucidate the genesis of the deposit. The sulfur isotope analysis revealed that the δ34S values of metal sulfides range from 2.0‰ to 12.1‰, with a mean of 7.8‰, displaying a multimodal distribution. Notably, pyrrhotite from the copper-iron sulfide stage exhibited relatively low δ34S values(mean 3.5‰), akin to mantle-derived sulfur, whereas galena and sphalerite from the lead-zinc sulfide stage showed higher δ34S values (mean 10.3‰). This suggests that the early ore-forming fluid was predominantly magmatic hydrothermal in origin, with an increasing contribution from seawater over time. The lead isotope analysis indicated that the lead isotope compositions of metal sulfides were relatively homogeneous, with 206Pb/204Pb, 207Pb/204Pb, and 208Pb/204Pb values ranging from 18.394 to 18.733, 15.591 to 15.782, and 38.125 to 38.743, respectively. The observed values exhibit similarity to those found in intrusive rocks, yet they differ significantly from those of the host rocks. This suggests that the ore-forming materials were derived from a combination of magmatic hydrothermal fluids associated with felsic intrusive magmas and the deep metamorphic crystalline basement. The μ values of metal sulfides range from 9.44 to 9.80(mean 9.54), ω values from 34.54 to 38.13(mean 35.68), and Th/U ratios from 3.53 to 3.77(mean 3.62), indicating a crust-mantle mixed origin with a predominance of crustal components. Through a comprehensive analysis of the deposit’s geological characteristics and sulfur-lead isotope data, this study concludes that the Kukaazi deposit represents a distal skarn-type Cu-Pb-Zn polymetallic deposit associated with submarine volcanic activity. This research contributes novel geochemical data pertinent to the genesis of polymetallic deposits in the Western Kunlun Orogenic Belt and provides critical insights for regional mineral exploration efforts.
库喀阿孜多金属矿床是西昆仑造山带近年来发现的一处重要矿床,位于新疆叶城县境内。该矿床以铅、锌矿化为主,伴生Cu和W等多金属元素,成矿潜力较大。矿体主要呈透镜状或似层状赋存于中元古界长城系的灰白色条纹状大理岩、变硅质岩和白色粗晶大理岩的接触带或层间构造中。矿区主要有KⅠ、KⅡ和KⅢ共3个矿段,其中,KⅠ矿段以铜锌矿化为主,伴生Pb和W等元素;KⅡ矿段则以铅锌矿化为主,局部见磁铁矿化(汪玉会等,2013;Zafar et al,2019)。受地理位置偏远和交通不便等自然条件限制,该矿床前期地质基础工作相对薄弱,整体研究程度较低,关于库喀阿孜多金属矿床的成矿物质来源及成因机制,学术界尚存在较大争议。一方面,矿区周围岩浆岩发育,且矿床产于造山带环境,暗示其可能与岩浆热液活动有关;另一方面,其层状和似层状产出特征又暗示着沉积或喷流沉积成因。前人研究虽然对矿床地质特征进行了初步描述,但缺乏关键的地球化学示踪数据,特别是系统的Pb同位素组成研究尚未开展。Pb同位素作为追踪成矿物质来源、揭示成矿地质过程及限定矿床形成时代的有力工具(Lin et al,2011;Darling et al,2012;Pettke et al,2012;Bao et al,2016;Yuan et al,2016;Chen et al,2017;贾文彬等,2018),在解决此类成因争议中具有不可替代的作用。
库喀阿孜多金属矿床围岩由灰白色条纹状大理岩、黑云母石英板岩、云母石英板岩、云母长石石英板岩、灰色凝灰质大理岩、变钙质凝灰岩、棕色变质凝灰质硅质岩、灰黑色变凝灰岩夹浅绿色硅质岩、黑灰色变凝灰岩、灰白色变流纹质凝灰岩、肉红色石榴子石矽卡岩、绿色透辉石岩、棕色钾长硅质岩和乳白色钠长石岩等组成(汪玉会等,2013),这些岩性因地层薄而无法完整显示出来。层理走向为160°~210°,倾角为60°~80°(图2和图3)(Leng et al,2019)。区内工程控制的矿体共有13个,主要以透镜状和似层状发育在中元古界长城系灰白色条纹状大理岩与绿色绿泥石石英板岩之间的石榴石类矽卡岩中,大理岩与变流纹质凝灰岩之间,以及白色粗晶大理岩和灰白色变流纹质凝灰岩中。矿区断层主要有5条,走向大致为NE向,以平移断层为主,对矿体具有一定的破坏作用(汪玉会等,2013)。矿区内出露有中酸性岩浆岩,主要分布于矿区北部和南部,岩性以加里东期二长岩和花岗闪长岩为主,另出露有少量的钾长花岗岩。这些岩体出露宽度在数百米至数千米不等,与变质岩呈侵入接触关系,但在接触带未见矽卡岩(Zhang et al,2014)。
矿床以铅锌矿化为主,伴生有铜、钨、银、镉、铋和铁等多种金属矿化。矿区探明铅资源量10.5万t(平均品位为3.69%),锌资源量4 200 t(平均品位为1.30%),铜资源量2 000 t(平均品位为0.31%),银资源量25 t(平均品位为33×10-6),WO3资源量大于5 000 t(平均品位为0.2%)(Leng et al,2019)。矿区内矿石矿物主要为闪锌矿、方铅矿、黄铜矿、磁铁矿和磁黄铁矿,脉石矿物以石英、方解石和钙铝榴石为主。主要矿物共生组合为闪锌矿+黄铜矿+磁黄铁矿+方铅矿+黄铁矿+透辉石+石榴子石+石英±碳酸盐±白钨矿±毒砂±黝铜矿±绿帘石±绿泥石(汪玉会等,2013)。矿石常见有胶状、竹叶状、自形粒状、半自形—他形粒状和固溶体结构,矿石构造主要有块状、浸染状、团块状和脉状。围岩蚀变主要有矽卡岩化、绿泥石化、绿帘石化、碳酸盐化和硅化等。
此外,本研究系统采集了34件金属硫化物、7件侵入岩和12件赋矿围岩样品,共计53件样品进行Pb同位素测试。Pb同位素测试工作在核工业北京地质研究所完成,所用仪器为Isoprobe-T热电离质谱仪。具体分析流程如下:(1)称取适量样品置于聚四氟乙烯坩埚中,依次加入氢氟酸(HF)和高氯酸(HClO4)进行消解,蒸干后加盐酸(HCl)复溶并再次蒸干,再用0.5 N HBr溶液溶解样品以备铅的分离;(2)将溶解液导入经预处理的强碱性阴离子交换树脂柱中,依次使用0.5 N HBr和2 N HCl淋洗,最后以6 N HCl洗脱铅组分,洗脱液蒸干后供质谱检测;(3)采用热表面电离质谱法测定Pb同位素组成,对于1 μg铅样品,²⁰⁸Pb/²⁰⁴Pb的测试精度优于0.005%。NBS981标准物质的测定结果(2σ)为:208Pb/206Pb=2.1681±0.0008,207Pb/206Pb=0.91464±0.00033,²⁰⁴Pb/²⁰⁶Pb=0.059042±0.000037。
由于Pb同位素在物质迁移和矿质沉淀中几乎不发生分馏作用,导致Pb同位素变化的主要因素是放射性元素U和Th的衰变。岩浆演化和分异作用、热液、变质作用和风化过程均有可能改变U/Pb和Th/Pb比值,因此通过分析岩石和矿物中的Pb同位素组成可以研究成矿物质来源和矿床成因(Macfarlane et al,1990;Chiaradia et al,2004)。
Pb同位素中μ值、ω值和Th/U比值的变化反映了矿床所经历的地质过程信息,可以用来推断矿床中铅的来源。前人研究认为,高μ值(大于9.58)的铅通常来自U和Th相对富集的上部地壳(Zartman et al,1981;吴开兴等,2002),μ值较低和ω值较高的铅通常来自上地幔(Kamona et al,1999),而μ值较低和ω值较低的铅指示下地壳来源(Doe et al,1979;吴开兴等,2002)。库喀阿孜多金属矿床中金属硫化物的μ值为9.44~9.80(平均值为9.54),小于上地壳铅的μ值(9.58),但明显大于原始地幔铅的μ值(8.92);ω值为34.54~38.13(平均值为35.68),略低于地壳铅的平均值(ω=36.84),而高于地幔铅的ω值(31.84)(Doe et al,1979);Th/U比值为3.53~3.77,平均值为3.62,略高于地幔的Th/U比值(3.45),而低于地壳的Th/U比值(4)。综合上述特征,推测库喀阿孜多金属矿床矿石铅为壳幔混合来源,且以地壳来源为主。
库喀阿孜多金属矿床的含矿岩系为一套浅变质岩系,由大理岩、石榴子石矽卡岩和绿色透辉石岩等组成,大理岩(或粗晶大理岩)中主要矿物为方解石,或含少量的石英和蒙脱石等矿物,具有细晶、中—粗粒结构,纹层状和块状构造;石榴子石矽卡岩中主要矿物为方解石、石英和钙铝榴石,其次含有少量蒙脱石和伊利石等矿物,岩石具斑块状构造,其中的石英颗粒非常细,石榴石常呈1~3 mm大小的斑点状集合体或浸染状分布;绿色透辉石岩中主要矿物为辉石,此外含有少量的石英、蒙脱石、角闪石和高岭石矿物(汪玉会等,2013)。从矿体产出特征来看,库喀阿孜多金属矿床的矿体多呈透镜状或似层状;地表矿化蚀变在横向上分带不明显,在垂向上则表现出一定规律:地表硅化较强,向深部逐渐减弱,绿泥石化则相应增强。矿物组成主要为黄铁矿、方铅矿、黄铜矿和闪锌矿;矿石构造以脉状、网脉状、团块状、角砾状和浸染状为主。Leng et al(2018)对辉钼矿和白钨矿的稀土元素分析结果进一步证实,该矿床形成于大陆弧环境下的矽卡岩成矿系统。矿区和外围花岗岩体的锆石U-Pb年龄为461~452 Ma(汪玉会等,2013;陶再礼等,2022),属于加里东期,表明矿床的形成可能与加里东期原特提斯洋的闭合有关。
前人对该矿床金属矿物的微量元素分析结果表明,闪锌矿微量元素特征显示该矿床属于矽卡岩型(Leng et al,2019)。矿区内围岩蚀变十分发育,主要包括矽卡岩化、绿泥石化、绿帘石化、碳酸盐化和硅化(梁东等,2022)。大兴安岭南段白音诺尔铅锌矿床是我国典型的矽卡岩型铅锌矿床,其成矿岩体主要为花岗闪长岩和闪长玢岩,部分矿体产于正长斑岩与大理岩接触带,矿石以方铅矿和闪锌矿为主,蚀变类型包括绿帘石化和矽卡岩化等,构造环境为大陆弧环境,矿化分带明显。对比分析表明,库喀阿孜多金属矿床的特征与大兴安岭白音诺尔铅锌矿床及其他典型矽卡岩型矿床具有相似性(Meinert et al,2005;王瑞良,2023)。
BaoZ A, YuanH L, ZongC L,et al,2016.Simultaneous determination of trace elements and lead isotopes in fused silicate rock powders using a boron nitride vessel and fsLA-(MC)-ICP-MS[J].Journal of Analytical Atomic Spectrometry,31(4):1012-1022.
[2]
ChenF C, DengJ, ShuQ H,et al,2017.Geology,fluid inclusion and stable isotopes(O,S) of the Hetaoping distal skarn Zn-Pb deposit,northern Baoshan block,SW China[J].Ore Geology Reviews,90:913-927.
[3]
ChaussidonM, LorandJ P,1990.Sulphur isotope composition of orogenic spinel lherzolite massifs from Ariege (North-Eastern Pyrenees,France):an ion microprobe study[J].Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta,54(10):2835-2846.
[4]
ChiaradiaM, FontbotéL, PaladinesA,2004.Metal sources in mineral deposits and crustal rocks of Ecuador(1° N-4° S):a lead isotope synthesis[J].Economic Geology,99(6):1085-1106.
[5]
DarlingJ R, StoreyC D, HawkesworthC J,et al,2012.In-situ Pb isotope analysis of Fe-Ni-Cu sulphides by laser ablation multi-collector ICPMS:new insights into ore formation in the Sudbury impact melt sheet[J].Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta,99:1-17.
JiangY H, JiangS Y, LingH F,et al,2002.Petrology and geochemistry of shoshonitic plutons from the western Kunlun orogenic belt,Xinjiang,northwestern China:implications for granitoid geneses[J].Lithos,63(3/4):165-187.
[9]
KamonaA F, LévêqueJ, FriedrichG,et al,1999.Lead isotopes of the carbonate-hosted Kabwe,Tsumeb,and Kipushi Pb-Zn-Cu sulphide deposits in relation to Pan African orogenesis in the Damaran-Lufilian Fold Belt of Central Africa[J].Mineralium Deposita,34(3):273-283.
[10]
LengC B, WangY H, ZhangX C,et al,2018.Constraints of molybdenite Re-Os and scheelite Sm-Nd ages on mineralization time of the Kukaazi Pb-Zn-Cu-W deposit,Western Kunlun,NW China[J].Acta Geochimica,37(1):47-59.
[11]
LengC B, WangW, YeL,et al,2019.Genesis of the late Ordovician Kukaazi Pb-Zn deposit in the western Kunlun orogen,NW China:new insights from in-situ trace elemental compositions of base metal sulfides[J].Journal of Asian Earth Sciences,184:103995.
[12]
LinY, CookN J, CiobanuC L,et al,2011.Trace and minor elements in sphalerite from base metal deposits in South China:a LA-ICPMS study[J].Ore Geology Reviews,39(4):188-217.
[13]
MatternF, SchneiderW,2000.Suturing of the proto- and paleo-Tethys oceans in the western Kunlun (Xinjiang,China)[J].Journal of Asian Earth Sciences,18(6):637-650.
[14]
MacfarlaneA W, MarcetP, LeHurayA P,et al,1990.Lead isotope provinces of the Central Andes inferred from ores and crustal rocks[J].Economic Geology,85(8):1857-1880.
OhmotoH,1986. Stable isotope geochemistry of ore deposits[J].Reviews in Mineralogy and Geochemistry,6(1): 491-559.
[17]
PettkeT, OberliF, AudétatA,et al,2012.Recent developments in element concentration and isotope ratio analysis of individual fluid inclusions by laser ablation single and multiple collector ICP-MS[J].Ore Geology Reviews,44:10-38.
SakaiH,1968.Isotopic properties of sulfur compounds in hydrothermal processes[J].Geochemical Journal,2(1):29-49.
[20]
XiaoW J, WindleyB F, ChenH L,et al,2002.Carboniferous-Triassic subduction and accretion in the western Kunlun,China:implications for the collisional and accretionary tectonics of the northern Tibetan Plateau[J].Geology,30(4):295.
[21]
XiaoW J, WindleyB F, LiuD Y,et al,2005.Accretionary tectonics of the western Kunlun Orogen,China:a Paleozoic-early Mesozoic,long-lived active continental margin with implications for the growth of southern Eurasia[J].The Journal of Geology,113(6):687-705.
[22]
YuanH L, YuanW T, ChengC,et al,2016.Evaluation of lead isotope compositions of NIST NBS 981 measured by thermal ionization mass spectrometer and multiple-collector inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometer[J].Solid Earth Sciences,1(2):74-78.
[23]
ZhangZ W, ShenN P, PengJ T,et al,2014.Syndeposition and epigenetic modification of the strata-bound Pb-Zn-Cu deposits associated with carbonate rocks in western Kunlun,Xinjiang,China[J].Ore Geology Reviews,62:227-244.
[24]
ZafarT, LengC B, ZhangX C,et al,2019.Geochemical attributes of magmatic apatite in the Kukaazi granite from western Kunlun orogenic belt,NW China:implications for granite petrogenesis and Pb-Zn(-Cu-W) mineralization[J].Journal of Geochemical Exploration,204:256-269.
[25]
ZhangY, NiuY L, HuY,et al,2016.The syncollisional granitoid magmatism and continental crust growth in the West Kunlun Orogen,China—evidence from geochronology and geochemistry of the Arkarz pluton[J].Lithos,245:191-204.
[26]
ZhangC L, LuS N, YuH F,et al,2007.Tectonic evolution of the Western Kunlun orogenic belt in northern Qinghai-Tibet Plateau:evidence from zircon SHRIMP and LA-ICP-MS U-Pb geochronology[J].Science in China Series D:Earth Sciences,50(6):825-835.
[27]
ZhangX C, WangY H, LengC B,et al,2014.Geology,sulfur isotopes and scheelite Sm-Nd age of the Kukaazi Pb-Zn-(Cu-W) polymetallic deposit,Yecheng County,Xinjiang,China[J].Acta Geologica Sinica (English Edition),88():244-246.
ChenYongqing, HuangJingning, LuYingxiang,et al,2009.Geochemistry of elements,sulphur-lead isotopes and fluid inclusions from Jinla Pb-Zn-Ag poly-metallic ore field at the joint area across China and Myanmar border[J].Earth Science,34(4):585-594.
DongLianhui, XuXingwang, FanTingbin,et al,2015.Discovery of the Huoshaoyun super-large exhalative-sedimentary carbonate Pb-Zn deposit in the western Kunlun area and its great significance for regional metallogeny[J].Xinjiang Geology,33(1):41-50.
[34]
丁道桂,王道轩,刘伟新,1996.西昆仑造山带与盆地[M].北京:地质出版社. Ding Daogui,Wang Daoxuan,Liu Xinwei,1996.The western Kunlun orogenic belt and basin[M].Beijing:Geological Publishing House.
JiaWenbin, LiYongsheng, YanGuangsheng,et al,2018.Ore genesis of the Duocaima Pb-Zn deposit,Tuotuohe area,Qinghai Province,China:evidences from in situ S and Pb isotopes[J].Acta Petrologica Sinica,34(5):1285-1298.
LiuJianping, WangHe, LiShehong,et al,2010.Geological and geochemical features and geochronology of the Kayizi porphyry molybdenum deposit in the northern belt of western Kunlun,NW China[J].Acta Petrologica Sinica,26(10):3095-3105.
LiangDong, WanShengnan, ZhangZhixin,et al,2022. Geological characteristics and deposit genesis analysis of the Kukaazi lead-zinc mine in West Kunlun[J].Xinjiang Youse Jinshu,45(2):66-68.
[41]
孙海田,李纯杰,吴海,等,2003.西昆仑金属成矿省概论[M].北京:地质出版社. Sun Haitian,Li Chunjie,Wu Hai,2003.Introduction to metallogenic province of west Kunlun[M].Beijing:Geological Publishing House.
TaoZaili, YinJiyuan, YuanChao,et al,2022.Petrogenesis of Late Ordovician intrusive rocks in the West Kunlun orogenic belt:constraints on the subduction process of the Proto-Tethys Ocean[J].Acta Petrologica Sinica,38(11):3321-3340.
WangHe, LiPei, MaHuadong,et al,2017.Discovery of the Bailongshan superlarge lithium-rubidium deposit in Karakorum,Hetian,Xinjiang,and its prospecting implication[J].Geotectonica et Metallogenia,41(6):1053-1062.
WuKaixing, HuRuizhong, BiXianwu,et al,2002.Ore lead isotopes as a tracer for ore-forming material sources:a review[J].Geology-geochemistry,30(3):73-81.
WangYuhui, LengChengbiao, ZhangXingchun,2013.A preliminary study on elemental geochemistry and geochronology of intermediate-acidic intrusive rocks from the Kukaazi Pb-Zn-(Cu-W) polymetallic deposit,Yecheng County,Xinjiang[J].Bulletin of Mineralogy,Petrology and Geochemistry,32(6):736-745.
[50]
王瑞良,2023.大兴安岭南段白音诺尔铅锌矿床成矿机制[D].北京:中国地质大学(北京). Wang Ruiliang,2023.Metallogenic mechanism of the Baiyinnuoer Pb-Zn deposit in the Southern Great Xing’an Range[D].Beijing:China University of Geosciences.
XuZhiqin, LiSitian, ZhangJianxin,et al,2011.Paleo-Asian and Tethyan tectonic systems with docking the Tarim block[J].Acta Petrologica Sinica,27(1):1-22.
ZhengYongfei, XuBaolong, ZhouGentao,2000.Geochemical studies of stable isotopes in minerals[J].Earth Science Frontiers,7(2):299-320.
[55]
朱炳泉,李献华,戴橦谟,等,1998.地球科学中同位素体系理论与应用——兼论中国大陆壳幔演化[M].北京:科学出版社. Zhu Bingquan,Li Xianhua,Dai Tongmo,et al,1998.Theory and application of isotope system in earth science: discussion on the evolution of the crust and mantle of China [M].Beijing:Science Press.
ZhangQian, PanJiayong, ShaoShuxun,2000.An interpretation of ore lead sources from lead isotopic compositions of some ore deposits in China[J].Geochimica,29(3):231-238.