As shallow mineral resources become increasingly exhausted, metal mining operations are progressively extending to greater depths. These deep mining environments are inherently complex and challenging, often characterized by high stress, elevated temperatures, significant osmotic pressure, a heigh tened risk of rock bursts, and considerable mining-induced disturbances. Particularly for fractured ore bodies situated beneath water bodies, buildings, and transportation routes—collectively termed as “three-under” conditions—mining operations are required to adhere to stringent ecological standards, including zero surface subsidence and the protection of river ecosystems. Consequently, ensuring safe and efficient mining under these conditions presents a significant challenge that demands urgent attention. In response to this issue, this study examines a deeply situated, steeply dipping, thick, and massive fractured ore body within a lead-zinc mine located in a scenic area of Nanjing. The research focuses on the selection of appropriate mining methods and the optimization of mining structure parameters.Initially, a comprehensive evaluation system incorporating 13 core indicators was developed to address multidimensional requirements such as mining technology, economics, safety, and environmental compatibility. The analytic hierarchy process (AHP) was employed to ascertain the weights of each indicator. This was integrated with a fuzzy mathematics-based comprehensive evaluation method to facilitate a scientific comparison among three preliminary schemes: the upward-seam layered stoping with backfilling method, the upward-seam horizontal layered pillar backfilling method, and the upward-seam backfilling method. The evaluation results reveal that the upward drift backfilling method emerged as the optimal mining scheme, attributed to its superior performance in operational safety, loss rate control, and minimal impact on the backfill body. Secondly, to validate and optimize the structural parameters of this scheme, the FLAC3D numerical simulation software was employed to systematically analyze the stability of the mining face within the specified ranges of drift height (3.5~4.5 m) and width (3~6 m). The results from both simulation and engineering applications indicate that at the maximum dimensions (4.5 m in height and 6 m in width), the maximum tensile stress (4.67 MPa) and compressive stress (68.99 MPa) in the surrounding rock remain below the strength limits of the ore and rock. Furthermore, the maximum roof settlement (4.02 mm) and maximum floor heave (4.11 mm) are significantly below the permissible values stipulated by codes. The distribution of the plastic zone is sporadic, with no continuous failure zone observed, thereby demonstrating that the working face maintains an overall stable state. By implementing the optimized plan within the engineering practices at the -725 to -775 m levels, the actual production capacity of the mining area increased to 196.4 t/d, and the ore loss rate was significantly reduced from 27% to 5%. This was achieved while concurrently meeting the ecological protection objective of zero surface subsidence. Through the integration of the analytic hierarchy Process (AHP)-fuzzy comprehensive evaluation with FLAC3D numerical simulation, this study developed a closed-loop technical system encompassing method selection, parameter optimization, and engineering validation. This approach not only effectively addressed the mining challenges associated with deep, fractured ore bodies under “three-under” conditions at this site but also established a replicable and scalable technical paradigm for safe, efficient, and environmentally sustainable mining under similar complex constraints.
浅部矿产资源的日益枯竭,正驱动金属矿开采活动持续向深部延伸(Chen et al,2015;张家林等,2024;王连成等,2025)。深部开采环境复杂严峻,其显著特点可概括为“四高一扰动”,具体包括岩层所处的高地应力状态、井下空间的高温环境、围岩的高渗透压条件、岩体自身的高岩爆倾向性,以及由于工程活动引发的强烈采动影响(邓红卫等,2017;秦秀山等,2022;陈邵杰等,2023;王少锋等,2024)。国际学者进一步揭示了深部硬岩在高应力环境下的复杂力学行为,如板裂化破坏和动态灾害(如岩爆),这些现象对围岩控制技术提出了更高要求(Du et al,2023;Lan et al,2025)。在此条件下,浅孔留矿法等传统方法在深部条件下暴露出采切工程量大、采空区安全隐患突出等问题,难以适应深部高效安全开采的需要(白宗荣,2023)。特别是对于赋存于水体、建筑物和交通线路下方的“三下”矿体,还需要满足地表生态环境保护与零塌陷的要求,这进一步加大了开采技术难度(程立年等,2019)。在此背景下,充填采矿法以其对围岩扰动小、回收率高和环境兼容性好等优点,逐渐成为深部矿体开采的重要技术方向(李夕兵等,2018;郭利杰等,2022;王勇等,2023)。
针对深部“三下”矿体破碎矿岩回采难题,国内外学者在采矿方法优选和参数优化方面进行了大量研究。在采矿方法优选方面,层次分析法(AHP)因其系统性好、能将复杂问题层次化和定量化,已成为该领域的经典和基础性方法(Wu et al,2019)。为了更精准地处理决策过程中的模糊性与不确定性,研究人员进一步将AHP与模糊数学、博弈论、理想点法(TOPSIS)等方法相集成,形成了诸如AHP-模糊综合评价、AHP-博弈论(任杰等,2025)和AHP-TOPSIS(武尚荣等,2025)等更强大的决策模型。此外,研究人员将机器学习技术运用于Optuna-RF智能模型,提高采矿方法选择精度(许杨丰等,2025),并运用Mathews稳定性图解法和实践经验来优选采矿方法(张建伟等,2025)。在采场参数优化方面,数值模拟技术已成为核心工具。学者们普遍采用FLAC3D和MIDAS(葛菊花等,2025)等软件,结合具体地质条件对采场结构参数(Zhao et al,2018;Lan et al,2025)、充填体人工假顶稳定性(Kumar et al,2026)和进路围岩压力(Yin et al,2024)进行精细化分析。此外,将初步确定参数的方法与数值模拟相结合,如运用Mathews理论结合数值模拟对结构参数进行优化(张志军等,2025);采用工程类比法,并结合FLAC3D数值模拟软件,对采场结构参数进行优化(彭晨鑫等,2025)。通过对比各采矿方法技术经济指标,并根据经验数据确定合理的采场结构参数,然后使用数值模拟进行验证(朱晨迪等,2024)。混沌遗传算法为多因素交互影响下高效寻求全局最优参数组合提供了先进手段(Lan et al,2025)。这些研究为深部及复杂条件下矿体安全高效开采奠定了坚实的理论与方法基础。
根据表2中的数据对判断矩阵进行一致性检验,计算得,表明矩阵具有满意的一致性,决策者的判断逻辑清晰,无显著矛盾。因此,通过AHP法计算得出的指标权重向量是可靠的,能够作为综合评价的依据, W 值为: W =[0.139,0.139,0.116,0.128,0.068,0.054,0.037,0.03,0.045,0.1,0.06,0.034,0.05]。
ChenH K, JiaoY Y, WangC,et al,2026.Mechanism of earthquakes induced by composite key stratum fracturing during deep mining[J/OL].Rock Mechanics and Rock Engineering.
[2]
DuK, LuoX Y, YangS G,et al,2023.An insight from energy index characterization to determine the proneness of rockburst for hard rock[J].Geomechanics for Energy and the Environment,35:100478.
[3]
KumarJ V, KolikipoguN R, PorathurJ L,et al,2026.Evaluation of stability of cemented pastefill as an artificial roof for underhand stoping-field and numerical modeling studies[J].Mining,Metallurgy & Exploration,43(2):1119-1134.
[4]
LanM, JiaH W, MaJ,2025.Optimization of stope dimensions using response surface method coupling a hybrid chaos-genetic algorithm[J].Scientific Reports,15:17223.
[5]
WuM Q, ZhangC H, LiuX N,et al,2019.Green supplier selection based on DEA model in interval-valued Pythagorean fuzzy environment[J].IEEE Access,7:108001-108013.
[6]
YinY, YangS J, HeY,et al,2024.Stability assessment of surrounding rock in downward mining route supported by slab‑wall backfll structure[J].Scientifc Reports,14:13706.
[7]
ZhaoT B, MaS Q, ZhangZ Y,2018.Ground control monitoring in backfilled strip mining under the metropolitan district:case study[J].International Journal of Geomechanics,18(7):05018003.
BaiZongrong,2023. Analysis and prevention of rock burst in huge thick coal seams under complex geological conditions [J].Mining Technology,23(1):94-97.
ChenShaojie, FengFan, LiXibing,et al,2023.Research progress and key issues of laboratory test and numerical simulation for slabbing failure in hard rock under complex mining conditions[J].Journal of China University of Mining & Technology,52(5):868-888.
ChengLinian, LiXiaogang, YeZhenhua,et al,2019.Surface stability analysis of “three under” mining within subsidence basin in a gold mine[J].Metal Mine,48(3):56-61.
DengHongwei, YangYiquan, DengJunren,et al,2017.Study on mining sequence of deep orebody under high stress environment below goaf[J].黄金科学技术,25(2):62-69.
GeJuhua, LiuYanbin, FeiHanqiang,2025.Optimization research on the structure parameters of filling stope based on MIDAS numerical simulation[J].Mining Research and Development,45(6):32-38.
GuoLijie, LiuGuangsheng, MaQinghai,et al,2022.Research progress on mining with backfill technology of underground metalliferous mine[J].Journal of China Coal Society,47(12):4182-4200.
LuChangyu, YangJianmin, ChenQihang,2024.Assessment of deep-sea mining vehicle traversability based on analytic hierarchy process-fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method[J].Shipbuilding of China,65(3):135-149.
MengQingbin, WangRui, HanLijun,et al,2023.Surrounding rock disturbance effect of multi-middle section combined mining in stopes and support technology of mining roadway[J].Journal of Central South University (Science and Technology),54(3):930-943.
PengChenxin, HuangDeyong, DuanZefeng,et al,2025.Study on optimization of point pillar parameters under artificial roof of a copper mine[J].Mining Research and Development,45(1):48-54.
QinXiushan, ChenHe, LiuJianpo,et al,2022.Mining environment monitoring and dynamic control technology of ground pressure in deep large ore sections[J].The Chinese Journal of Nonferrous Metals,32(12):3871-3882.
RenJie, LiJiaoqun, LuZengxiang,et al,2025.Optimal selection of the mining method based on game theory-subjective and objective multi-attribute combined weighting[J].Mining Research and Development,45(3):24-30.
WangLiancheng, ShaoAnlin, QuFuming,et al,2025. Current status and prospects of mining technology in metal mines [J]. Chinese Journal of Engineering, 47(5):971-983.
WangQiwei, ZhangJianwei, WangGuannan,et al,2024.Research on optimization of mining structure parameters based on FLAC3D numerical simulation[J].Shanxi Metallurgy,47(5):25-28.
FanKaixin, ZhouZilong,2024. Conception and prospects for catastrophe mechanism and the induced modification method of high stressed heterogeneous rock in deep underground [J/OL]. Journal of Mining & Safety Engineering,1-16.
WangYong, WuAixiang, YangJun,et al,2023.Progress and prospective of the mining key technology for deep metal mines[J].Chinese Journal of Engineering,45(8):1281-1292.
WuShangrong, ChenBanghong, FeiZhiwen,2025.Optimization of mining methods for gently inclined phosphate ore body based on improved AHP-TOPSIS model[J].Mining and Metallurgical Engineering,45(4):52-57.
ZengLingyi, LiaoJiubo, WangXiaotian,et al,2025. Research on optimization of structural parameters of a tungsten mine stope based on orthogonal test and numerical simulation[J].Mining Technology,25(1):12-15.
ZhangChao, FangYingtao, DongZhijie,et al,2025.Testability index allocation method based on fuzzy analytic network process and group decision-making[J].Systems Engineering and Electronics,47(8):2570-2580.
ZhangJialin, YangFan, ZhangWang,et al,2024.Innovation effectiveness analysis and technology management reflection of deep resource exploitation[J].Journal of Mining & Safety Engineering,41(3):450-461.
ZhangJianwei, LiYuze, ZhenLü,et al,2025.Optimization of pillar mining method based on Mathews method in Hongling lead-zinc mine[J].Nonferrous Metals (Mine Section),77(2):80-85.
ZhangZhijun, YangNing, RenQinglin, et al,2025. Optimization analysis of stope structure parameters of upward layered point pillar filling mining method in a mine [J].Mining Research and Development,45(10):43-52.
ZhuChendi, ZhuShengli, JiangKe,et al,2024.Pillar recovery scheme and stope structure parameter optimization of a molybdenum mine[J].Mining Research and Development,44(5):1-8.