Optic neuritis, one of the most common vision-threatening optic nerve disorder in young and middle-aged individuals, refers to a group of inflammatory conditions affecting the optic nerve
[1]. Based on various factors such as etiology, clinical presentation, affected site, and recovery, optic neuritis can be classified into different types. Clinically, optic neuritis is divided into typical and atypical forms
[1-3]. Typical optic neuritis is often self-limiting and carries a risk of developing into multiple sclerosis (MS) after an episode
[4]. In contrast, atypical optic neuritis may or may not be associated with systemic diseases and is not necessarily linked to MS. Clinically, MS-related optic neuritis (MS-ON) is diagnosed and subsequently treated with appropriate preventive measures, while atypical optic neuritis requires a more comprehensive etiological workup
[2]. Early identification of the underlying cause, accurate diagnosis, and personalized treatment can help reduce vision loss and improve the quality of life in patients with optic neuritis. This study reports the clinical data of a patient diagnosed with bilateral atypical optic neuritis who presented with monocular visual acuity loss, with the aim of improving clinicians' understanding of atypical optic neuritis and emphasizing the importance of timely etiological investigation and individualized management.
1 Case presentation
A 40-year-old male patient presented with a 2-week history of left-eye vision loss and a sensation of a black shadow obstructing his vision. The patient reported a sudden onset of vision loss in the left eye, accompanied by the sensation of a black shadow, but without ocular pain during eye movements. He had no significant medical, surgical, or trauma history, and had not experienced any recent infections. One week prior, he was diagnosed with left-eye optic neuritis at another facility but did not receive treatment.
Ophthalmic examination revealed: Right eye visual acuity 20/20, left eye visual acuity 20/40, normal intraocular pressure, and normal color vision in both eyes. Eye movements were normal, and anterior segment examination was unremarkable. Right eye pupils responded normally to direct light, while the left eye showed sluggish pupil light reaction with relative afferent pupillary defect (RAPD). Fundus examination revealed optic disc swelling in both eyes, with a flat retina. Mild optic disc vascular dilatation was noted, and a linear hemorrhage was seen around the left optic nerve head (Figure
1A and
1B). The initial diagnosis was bilateral optic neuritis.
To further clarify the diagnosis, a comprehensive ocular examination was performed. Visual field testing (Figure
2A and
2B) revealed a temporal superior and nasal inferior para-central scotoma in the right eye and widespread visual field defects in the left eye, leaving only a tubular field in the lower part. Fluorescein fundus angiography (FFA) showed early optic disc leakage in the right eye with poorly defined borders in the late phase; in the left eye, the optic disc vessels exhibited weak filling early on with mild leakage and unclear borders in the late phase. No leakage was observed in the macula of either eye (
Figure 3). Multifocal electroretinography (mfERG) revealed decreased function of the foveal cone cells in both eyes (Figure
4A and
4B). Pattern visual evoked potential (PVEP) showed normal results in the right eye but decreased amplitude and prolonged latency in the left eye (
Figure 5A). Brain and optic nerve enhanced magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scans showed no significant abnormalities in the brain or optic nerves (
Figure 6A). These findings supported the diagnosis of bilateral atypical optic neuritis.
Systemic examination revealed a positive result for the Treponema pallidum particle agglutination (TPPA) test. Upon further history taking, the patient admitted to a relevant past history but had not received regular treatment. Given this, the possibility of syphilitic optic neuritis was considered. After a consultation with the neurology department, the patient was advised to undergo enhanced magnetic resonance angiography (MRA) of the brain. Additionally, to rule out an infectious etiology, lumbar puncture was performed to analyze cerebrospinal fluid (CSF).
The patient was initially treated with 80 mg of intravenous steroids and supportive therapy, including vasodilators and neuroprotective agents. Subsequent enhanced MRI and MRA of the brain showed no significant abnormalities. No abnormalities were found in the orbit or optic nerves, and no white matter lesions or brain parenchymal changes were observed. Digital subtraction angiography (DSA) showed no significant findings (
Figure 6B). Further serological testing for syphilis-specific antibodies showed TPPA positive (1: 1 280), but the rapid plasma reagin (RPR) test was negative. Lumbar puncture revealed normal intracranial pressure and no abnormalities in CSF routine, biochemical, or smear tests. Syphilis IgG, IgM, and venereal disease research laboratory (VDRL) tests were all negative, thus ruling out syphilitic optic neuritis.
Given the inability to rule out idiopathic optic neuritis, further serum testing for specific antibodies related to central nervous system demyelinating diseases was performed. Using a cell-based assay (CBA) method, antibodies against aquaporin-4 (AQP4), myelin oligodendrocyte glycoprotein (MOG), and myelin basic protein (MBP) were all negative (
Figure 7). Finally, genetic testing revealed a mutation at the
T14484C locus, leading to a diagnosis of Leber hereditary optic neuropathy (LHON).
After 1 week of steroid treatment, the patient reported slight improvement in left-eye vision and a reduction in the sensation of the black shadow, though it had not completely resolved. On re-examination: Right eye visual acuity 20/20, left eye visual acuity 20/25, with no significant abnormalities in the anterior segment. The left eye still exhibited a relative afferent pupillary defect. Fundus examination showed optic disc swelling and mild vascular dilatation in both eyes, with deep hemorrhage on the nasal side of the left optic nerve head. These findings had improved slightly compared to previous examinations (Figure
1C and
1D). Visual field (Figure
2C and
2D), mFERG (Figure
4C and
4D), and PVEP results (
Figure 5B) showed slight improvement.
2 Discussion
Optic neuritis, a condition characterized by inflammation of the optic nerve, typically presents as subacute, unilateral, painful vision loss
[3]. It can be classified into various types. According to the Chinese expert consensus on the diagnosis and treatment of optic neuritis (2014)
[5], optic neuritis can be categorized into four types based on etiology: Idiopathic, infectious and infectious-related, autoimmune, and unclassified optic neuritis. The etiological diagnosis of optic neuritis determines the treatment regimen, duration, and prognosis for the patient. However, the clinical manifestations of different types of optic neuritis are often similar and can be confusing, especially in the case of atypical optic neuritis, where treatment and prognosis are closely tied to the underlying cause
[3, 6-8]. Therefore, a comprehensive diagnostic approach is required for differential diagnosis.
Among the various types, syphilitic optic neuritis (SON) has been increasing in incidence in recent years. It presents with highly variable clinical manifestations, often insidiously, and can mimic various infectious and autoimmune optic neuritis conditions. This makes it prone to misdiagnosis and missed diagnosis, warranting attention. According to the 2022 Expert Consensus on the Diagnosis and Treatment of Syphilitic Optic Neuritis in China
[7], the diagnosis of syphilitic optic neuritis requires the inclusion of non-treponemal tests (NTT) such as the VDRL slide test, RPR test, and the toluidine red unheated serum test (TRUST). Additionally, positive results in treponemal tests such as the fluorescent treponemal antibody absorption test (FTA-ABS), TPPA, treponemal particle agglutination test (TPHA), enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA), and chemiluminescent immunoassay (CLIA) are required. Finally, syphilitic serology test of CSF must also be positive. However, it is important to note that in a small number of late-stage cases, NTT may yield negative results. Furthermore, given the diverse imaging findings in SON patients, both CT and MRI cannot provide direct diagnostic evidence. Therefore, if SON is suspected, comprehensive syphilis serological testing should be performed, and the diagnosis should ultimately be confirmed through CSF analysis.
In the case of our patient, after completing the necessary tests, we found a positive result in the treponemal test (TT), a negative result in the NTT, and no abnormalities in the CSF, thus excluding syphilitic optic neuritis. However, since the patient’s brain MRI showed no obvious demyelinating changes, and anti-demyelinating optic neuritis antibodies were negative, we did not consider demyelinating optic neuritis (DON). Given the patient’s normal systemic infection markers, infectious optic neuritis was also unlikely. Furthermore, the ocular examination did not show findings consistent with ischemic optic neuropathy.
Considering the patient’s age, the acute vision loss in the left eye, bilateral optic disc swelling, and central visual field defects in both eyes, we proceeded with routine tests, which did not reveal clear ocular or neurological causes. Therefore, we considered the possibility of LHON and performed mitochondrial genetic testing. Ultimately, the diagnosis of LHON was confirmed through the relevant genetic testing.
LHON is a rare, genetic optic neuropathy caused by mutations in mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA)
[9-10]. Due to the heterogeneity in its clinical presentation, the age of onset, type of mutation, disease progression, and prognosis can vary significantly among patients. In the early stages, the clinical manifestations are non-specific. Typically, it presents as acute or subacute vision loss in one eye in young adult males, often progressing to involve the other eye within a few weeks to months. Some patients may have mild symptoms, while others may experience rapid progression to severe vision loss. Additionally, due to its maternal inheritance pattern, many patients do not have a family history, though vision loss is common in young males. While LHON may show signs of optic disc congestion, capillary dilation, and other changes in the acute phase, these ocular and systemic findings are not specific to LHON, making diagnosis reliant on genetic testing. Consequently, LHON is difficult to identify in its early stages.
In summary, when young patients, especially males, present with acute or subacute vision loss, with bilateral involvement occurring sequentially or simultaneously, and exhibit atypical optic neuritis fundus findings, but routine examinations do not reveal obvious ocular or neurological causes, LHON should be considered regardless of family history. Genetic testing is recommended for early diagnosis and prompt treatment.