基于多模型耦合的北京市门头沟区土地利用变化模拟与碳储量评估

Simulation of Land Use Change and Carbon Storage Assessment in Mentougou District, Beijing Based on a Multi-model Coupling Framework

摘要

【目的】在全球气候变化加剧与“双碳”目标持续推进的背景下，探究北京市门头沟区的土地利用变化及碳储量动态变化趋势，以及对区域生态安全格局与城市可持续发展的影响。【方法】以门头沟区为研究对象，基于2000、2010、2020年共3个时期的土地利用数据，构建系统动力学（system dynamics, SD）模型、斑块生成土地利用模拟（patch-generating land use simulation, PLUS）模型与生态系统服务评估与权衡（integrated valuation of ecosystem services and trade-offs, InVEST）模型的多模型耦合框架，在共享社会经济路径与典型浓度路径（shared socioeconomic pathways-representative concentration pathways, SSP-RCPs）情景框架下，设置3种未来发展情景，对土地利用变化及其碳储量响应进行模拟与评估。【结果】研究结果表明：1）不同情景下土地利用变化呈现显著差异，建设用地扩张与生态用地保护之间存在明显权衡关系；2）维持“林地-草地-水体”的协同格局是提升区域碳储量的关键，中等辐射强迫情景最有利于门头沟区实现生态保护与经济发展的协同目标；3）在山地地形约束与严格空间管控背景下，碳储量在空间上呈现较明显的差异性，建设活动沿河谷和平缓区集聚对碳汇功能的影响尤为突出。【结论】构建了“土地利用-情景模拟-碳储量评估”的综合分析框架，可为门头沟区国土空间规划与低碳发展路径优化提供情景支撑，也为北京市生态优先与绿色发展战略的实施提供科学依据。

Abstract

[Objective] Against the background of intensifying global climate change and the advancement of carbon neutrality goals, extreme weather events impact the the Earth’s natural environment, human survival, and socioeconomic development. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) AR6 Synthesis Report: Climate Change 2023 states that the world must implement deep, rapid, and sustained emission reductions to address climate risks in the future. As major centers of energy consumption and carbon emissions, cities have become key units in achieving low-carbon transition goals. How to achieve the coordinated development of urban low-carbon transition and ecological security has emerged as a hot topic in current research. As Beijing’s only purely mountainous district and a typical mountainous, resource-based transition area, Mentougou District faces highly distinctive climate risks and land-use pressures. Changes in its land use and dynamics of carbon stocks hold significant implications for the regional ecological security landscape and urban sustainable development. [Methods] This study focuses on Mentougou District in Beijing and constructs an SD-PLUS-InVEST multi-model coupling framework to conduct a systematic analysis covering the entire process of “land use-scenario simulation-carbon stock assessment.” First, based on land use data from 2000, 2010, and 2020, a system dynamics (SD) model was developed and coupled. Scenario simulation parameters were set according to climate change projections and socioeconomic data under different Shared Socioeconomic Pathways and Representative Concentration Pathways (SSP-RCPs) scenarios to simulate land use demands under various scenarios. Second, the PLUS model was used to explicitly simulate future land-use spatial patterns. By establishing a land-use transition matrix and a development probability map, the model allocates macro-level demands to spatial units, thereby ensuring consistency between quantitative and spatial constraints. Finally, the InVEST model was used to calculate the total carbon stock and its spatial distribution for different scenarios. This study aims to elucidate the mechanisms underlying land use evolution during the transition period of mountainous cities and to provide decision-making references for low-carbon development in ecological conservation areas. [Results] The results indicate that: 1) Simulations based on the PLUS model reveal that under different SSP-RCPs scenarios, the area of ecologically sensitive farmland decreases significantly, water bodies are obviously regulated by policies, and the expansion pattern of construction land shows substantial spatial heterogeneity. This phenomenon of spatial displacement reflects the dynamic interplay between economic development needs and ecological conservation within the framework of the “farmland reclamation and compensation” policy. 2) Comparative scenario analysis indicates that the SSP2-4.5 scenario, characterized by moderate development intensity, is most conducive to the coordinated eco-economic development of Mentougou District. Under this scenario, carbon stocks steadily increase from 26.586 9 Tg in 2020 to 27.054 3 Tg in 2060, achieving enhanced carbon sequestration under conditions of moderate economic growth and mild climate warming. In contrast, regional carbon stocks under the SSP1-2.6 scenario are lower than those under SSP2-4.5, primarily due to the conversion of some forested land into grasslands with lower carbon density. This highlights the risk of internal functional degradation that mountainous ecological conservation areas may face under strict regulatory frameworks. Under the SSP5-8.5 scenario, urban land expands in a concentrated manner in the eastern Mentougou New Town, with both cropland and urban land encroaching upon high-carbon-density forested areas, leading to a significant decline in carbon stocks. 3) Analysis of land use optimization indicates that maintaining the synergistic effects of forest, grassland, and water bodies is key to increasing carbon stocks. The scale of construction land expansion must be controlled to prevent encroachment on high-carbon-sink forest areas; simultaneously, the layout of cropland should be optimized to avoid the conversion of marginal forest land into low-efficiency cropland. Such adjustments to the land use structure can enhance carbon stocks. 4) Analysis of the transformation and development pathway suggests a three-phase strategy: First, prioritize the ecological restoration of abandoned mining areas such as the Wangping Mine to increase carbon density in the restored zones, while simultaneously developing green industries such as eco-tourism and specialty agriculture; second, establish a spatial system comprising “new cities, characteristic towns, and ecological villages,” leveraging rail transit to achieve intensive development and focusing on the exploitation of abundant natural and rich cultural resources; finally, develop green industries such as eco-tourism to establish a mountainous economic development pathway that integrates high-quality green development in old industrial and mining areas with eco-tourism-driven prosperity for local residents, thereby laying a solid foundation for building a low-carbon city. [Conclusion] This study focuses on Mentougou District in Beijing, a mountainous urban area, and constructs a relatively accurate, comprehensive, and dynamic land-use simulation model. It simulates future land demand quantitatively from a macro, top-down perspective and simulates the spatial patterns of future land use from a micro, bottom-up perspective. The aim is to provide scenario simulations to support the development of future regional spatial planning in the district. It also offers a reference framework and scenario pathways for other mountainous and resource-based cities undergoing transformation to optimize land use and manage carbon sequestration in the context of climate change.

关键词

风景园林 / 土地利用 / 碳中和 / 碳储量 / 共享社会经济路径与典型浓度路径 / 山地型城市 / 情景模拟

Key words

landscape architecture / land use / carbon neutrality / carbon stock / SSP-RCPs / mountainous city / scenario simulation

参考文献

[1] 杨鑫， 高雯雯， 李莎， 等 . 基于遥感影像估算的北京中心城区碳储量与气候环境关联性研究[J]. 风景园林，2022， 29（5）： 31-37.

[2] Yang X， Gao W W， Li S， et al. Research on Correlation Between Carbon Storage Estimation Based on Remote Sensing Image and Climate Environment in Central Urban Area of Beijing[J]. Landscape Architecture，2022， 29（5）： 31-37.

[3] 蒋志， 李栋， 韩立峰， 等 . 北京西部地区气候变化及气候舒适度特征分析[J]. 内蒙古气象，2023（1）： 25-30.

[4] Jiang Z， Li D， Han L F， et al. Analysis of Climate Change and Climatic Comfort Characteristics in Western Beijing[J]. Meteorology Journal of Inner Mongolia，2023（1）： 25-30.

[5] 郭英， 申健， 刘晓晓， 等 . 北京门头沟区“23·7”特大暴雨诱发地质灾害特征及分布规律研究[J]. 中国防汛抗旱，2025， 35（3）： 39-45.

[6] Guo Y， Shen J， Liu X X， et al. Study on the Characteristics and Distribution Patterns of Geological Hazards Induced by the “23·7” Extreme Heavy Rainstorm in Mentougou District of Beijing City[J]. China Flood & Drought Management，2025， 35（3）： 39-45.

[7] Tobler W R . Cellular Geography[M]//Gale S，Olsson G. Philosophy in Geography. Dordrecht：Springer， 1979： 379-386.

[8] 黄子豪， 杜华强， 李雪建， 等 . 土地利用/覆盖变化及其对森林碳收支影响研究综述[J]. 遥感学报，2025， 29（1）： 49-69.

[9] Huang Z H， Du H Q， Li X J， et al. Review of Research on Land Use/Cover Change and Its Impact on Forest Carbon Balance[J]. National Remote Sensing Bulletin，2025， 29（1）： 49-69.

[10] Meentemeyer R K， Tang W W， Dorning M A， et al. FUTURES：Multilevel Simulations of Emerging Urban-Rural Landscape Structure Using a Stochastic Patch-Growing Algorithm[J]. Annals of the Association of American Geographers， 2013， 103（4）： 785-807.

[11] Chen Y M， Li X， Liu X P， et al. Modeling Urban Land-Use Dynamics in a Fast Developing City Using the Modified Logistic Cellular Automaton with a Patch-Based Simulation Strategy[J]. International Journal of Geographical Information Science， 2014， 28（2）： 234-255.

[12] Omrani H， Parmentier B， Helbich M， et al. The Land Transformation Model-Cluster Framework：Applying K-Means and the Spark Computing Environment for Large Scale Land Change Analytics[J]. Environmental Modelling & Software， 2019， 111： 182-191.

[13] Verburg P H， Soepboer W， Veldkamp A， et al. Modeling the Spatial Dynamics of Regional Land Use：The CLUE-S Model[J]. Environmental Management， 2002， 30（3）： 391-405.

[14] Ma S L， Huang J L， Wang X X， et al. Multi-scenario Simulation of Low-Carbon Land Use Based on the SD-FLUS Model in Changsha, China[J]. Land Use Policy， 2025， 148： 107418.

[15] Liang X， Guan Q F， Clarke K C， et al. Understanding the Drivers of Sustainable Land Expansion Using a Patch-Generating Land Use Simulation (PLUS) Model：A Case Study in Wuhan, China[J]. Computers, Environment and Urban Systems， 2021， 85： 101569.

[16] 庄子薛， 谢梦晴， 张文萍， 等 . 基于FLUS-InVEST模型的碳储量时空变迁及多情景模拟预测：以成德眉资地区为例[J]. 风景园林，2022， 29（5）： 38-44.

[17] Zhuang Z X， Xie M Q， Zhang W P， et al. Temporal and Spatial Changes and Multi-scenario Simulation Prediction of Carbon Storage Based on FLUS-InVEST Model：A Case Study of Chengdu−Deyang−Meishan−Ziyang Area[J]. Landscape Architecture，2022， 29（5）： 38-44.

[18] 虎瑞， 高艳红， 张鹏， 等 . 干旱沙区植被恢复与重建对碳循环关键过程的影响研究进展[J]. 中国沙漠，2025， 45（3）： 60-71.

[19] Hu R， Gao Y H， Zhang P， et al. Review on the Effects of Vegetation Revegetation on Key Carbon Cycle Processes in Arid Sandy Regions[J]. Journal of Desert Research，2025， 45（3）： 60-71.

[20] 邢笑天， 王琪， 赵佳俊， 等 . 耦合InVEST-PLUS模型的济南都市圈土地利用及碳储量变化研究[J]. 自然资源遥感，2025， 37（4）： 118-130.

[21] Xing X T， Wang Q， Zhao J J， et al. Investigating Land Use and Carbon Storage Changes in Jinan Metropolitan Circle Based on the InVEST-PLUS Coupled Model[J]. Remote Sensing for Natural Resources，2025， 37（4）： 118-130.

[22] 王春晓， 李明倩 . 基于文献计量的土地利用变化与碳汇评估交叉研究进展[J]. 生态学报，2024， 44（13）： 5893-5903.

[23] Wang C X， Li M Q . Research Progress on the Intersection of Land Use Change and Carbon Sequestration Assessment：A Bibliometric Analysis[J]. Acta Ecologica Sinica，2024， 44（13）： 5893-5903.

[24] Schröter D， Cramer W， Leemans R， et al. Ecosystem Service Supply and Vulnerability to Global Change in Europe[J]. Science， 2005， 310（5752）： 1333-1337.

[25] Zhu E Y， Deng J S， Zhou M M， et al. Carbon Emissions Induced by Land-Use and Land-Cover Change from 1970 to 2010 in Zhejiang, China[J]. Science of the Total Environment， 2019， 646： 930-939.

[26] Babbar D， Areendran G， Sahana M， et al. Assessment and Prediction of Carbon Sequestration Using Markov Chain and InVEST Model in Sariska Tiger Reserve, India[J]. Journal of Cleaner Production， 2021， 278： 123333.

[27] 邵壮， 陈然， 赵晶， 等 . 基于FLUS与InVEST模型的北京市生态系统碳储量时空演变与预测[J]. 生态学报，2022， 42（23）： 9456-9469.

[28] Shao Z， Chen R， Zhao J， et al. Spatio-Temporal Evolution and Prediction of Carbon Storage in Beijing’s Ecosystem Based on FLUS and InVEST Models[J]. Acta Ecologica Sinica，2022， 42（23）： 9456-9469.

[29] 王春晓， 邓孟婷， 汪雪飞， 等 . 基于PLUS-InVEST模型的碳储量时空演变与预测模拟[J]. 中国园林，2024， 40（6）： 70-76.

[30] Wang C X， Deng M T， Wang X F， et al. Spatial-Temporal Evolution and Prediction Simulation of Carbon Storage Based on PLUS-InVEST Model[J]. Chinese Landscape Architecture，2024， 40（6）： 70-76.

[31] 李思楠， 史雅娟， 钱力， 等 . 基于多情景土地利用模拟的碳储量时空演变及驱动机制分析：以湖州市为例[J]. 环境科学学报，2026， 46（6）： 390-401.

[32] Li S N， Shi Y J， Qian L， et al. Analysis of Spatiotemporal Evolution and Driving Mechanisms of Carbon Stock Based on Multi-scenario Land Use Simulation：A Case Study of Huzhou City[J]. Acta Scientiae Circumstantiae，2026， 46（6）： 390-401.

[33] 卢兴超， 徐宗学， 陈浩， 等 . 基于复杂网络的山地型区域洪涝灾害链风险评估：以北京市门头沟区为例[J]. 水科学进展，2026， 37（1）： 94-106.

[34] Lu X C， Xu Z X， Chen H， et al. Risk Assessment of Flooding Disaster Chains in Mountainous Area Based on Complex Network：Take Mentougou District, Beijing as an Example[J]. Advances in Water Science，2026， 37（1）： 94-106.

[35] 程琳琳， 李继欣， 娄尚， 等 . 矿产资源型城市矿业废弃地优化再利用对策：以北京市门头沟区为例[J]. 中国矿业，2013， 22（1）： 69-71.

[36] Cheng L L， Li J X， Lou S， et al. Optimization Reutilization Countermeasures of Mining Wasteland in Mineral Resource Cities[J]. China Mining Magazine，2013， 22（1）： 69-71.

[37] 李雪红， 金鑫， 张学斌， 等 . 基于SSP-RCP情景的甘肃省土地利用与碳储量动态演变及预测[J]. 环境科学，2025， 46（11）： 7058-7069.

[38] Li X H， Jin X， Zhang X B， et al. Dynamic Evolution and Prediction of Land Use and Carbon Storage in Gansu Province Based on SSP-RCP Scenario[J]. Environmental Science，2025， 46（11）： 7058-7069.

[39] Tebaldi C， Debeire K， Eyring V， et al. Climate Model Projections from the Scenario Model Intercomparison Project (ScenarioMIP) of CMIP6[J]. Earth System Dynamics， 2021， 12（1）： 253-293.

[40] Huang Z H， Li X J， Du H Q， et al. Simulating Future LUCC by Coupling Climate Change and Human Effects Based on Multi-phase Remote Sensing Data[J]. Remote Sensing， 2022， 14（7）： 1698.

[41] Fan Z M . Simulation of Land-Cover Change in Jing-Jin-Ji Region Under Different Scenarios of SSP-RCP[J]. Journal of Geographical Sciences， 2022， 32（3）： 421-440.

[42] van Vuuren D P， Kriegler E， O’Neill B C， et al. A New Scenario Framework for Climate Change Research：Scenario Matrix Architecture[J]. Climatic Change， 2014， 122（3）： 373-386.

[43] Fan X W， Duan Q Y， Shen C W， et al. Global Surface Air Temperatures in CMIP6：Historical Performance and Future Changes[J]. Environmental Research Letters， 2020， 15（10）： 104056.

[44] Tian J X， Zhang Z X， Ahmed Z， et al. Projections of Precipitation over China Based on CMIP6 Models[J]. Stochastic Environmental Research and Risk Assessment， 2021， 35（4）： 831-848.

[45] Chen Y T， Liu A B， Cheng X . Quantifying Economic Impacts of Climate Change Under Nine Future Emission Scenarios Within CMIP6[J]. Science of the Total Environment， 2020， 703： 134950.

[46] Chen Y D， Guo F， Wang J C， et al. Provincial and Gridded Population Projection for China Under Shared Socioeconomic Pathways from 2010 to 2100[J]. Scientific Data， 2020， 7： 83.

[47] 黄艳， 刘晓曼， 高兵兵， 等 . 耦合PLUS-InVEST模型的京津风沙源区碳储量变化及多情景预测[J]. 环境科学，2025， 46（9）： 5741-5751.

[48] Huang Y， Liu X M， Gao B B， et al. Changes in Carbon Storage and Multi-scenario Prediction in the Beijing-Tianjin Sandstorm Source Region Using a Coupled PLUS-InVEST Model[J]. Environmental Science，2025， 46（9）： 5741-5751.

[49] Nelson E， Mendoza G， Regetz J， et al. Modeling Multiple Ecosystem Services, Biodiversity Conservation, Commodity Production, and Tradeoffs at Landscape Scales[J]. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment， 2009， 7（1）： 4-11.

[50] 王宏亮， 邱嘉政， 吴健生 . 双碳目标下呼包鄂城市群多情景土地利用优化分析[J]. 地理研究，2025， 44（3）： 656-675.

[51] Wang H L， Qiu J Z， Wu J S . Multi-scenario Land Use Optimization Analysis of the Hohhot-Baotou-Ordos Urban Agglomeration Under Dual Carbon Targets[J]. Geographical Research，2025， 44（3）： 656-675.

[52] He C Y， Zhang D， Huang Q X， et al. Assessing the Potential Impacts of Urban Expansion on Regional Carbon Storage by Linking the LUSD-Urban and InVEST Models[J]. Environmental Modelling & Software， 2016， 75： 44-58.

[53] 李敏 . 基于InVEST模型的生态系统服务功能评价研究：以北京延庆为例[D]. 北京： 北京林业大学，2016.

[54] Li M . Ecosystem Services Evaluation Based on InVEST Model：A Case Study of Yanqing, Beijing[D]. Beijing： Beijing Forestry University，2016.

[55] 何孟琦， 汪承平， 海燕， 等 . 长江三角洲地区生态环境与土地利用变化研究[J]. 地理空间信息，2023， 21（8）： 95-99.

[56] He M Q， Wang C P， Hai Y， et al. Research on Ecological Environment and Land-Use Change inYangtze River Delta[J]. Geospatial Information，2023， 21（8）： 95-99.

[57] Ma L， Shen C Y， Lou D， et al. Ecosystem Carbon Storage in Forest Fragments of Differing Patch Size[J]. Scientific Reports， 2017， 7： 13173.

[58] 杨文 . 长江流域城市蔓延多情景模拟及其对生态环境的影响[D]. 重庆： 重庆交通大学，2024： 58-59.

[59] Yang W. Multi-scenario Simulation of Urban Sprawl in the Yangtze River Basin and Its Impact on the Ecological Environment[D]. Chongqing： Chongqing Jiaotong University，2024： 58-59.

[60] Lin J Y， Li X， Wen Y Y， et al. Modeling Urban Land-Use Changes Using a Landscape-Driven Patch-Based Cellular Automaton (LP-CA)[J]. Cities， 2023， 132： 103906.

基金资助

国家自然科学基金“疏解背景下平原型城市边缘区生态空间演变与优化研究”(52108038)